Researchers led by Shane P. Singh of the University of Georgia investigated whether the common winner–loser gap in satisfaction with democracy stems from short-term emotions or from expectations about government performance. They reasoned that winning an election combines immediate joy with the power to make policy, so to isolate emotion they studied events that change mood but have no political consequences.
The team used three approaches: surveys around major sports finals and a lab experiment. They surveyed people in the Cincinnati and Los Angeles regions before and after the 2022 Super Bowl, and around the 2022 World Cup final between Argentina and France. Fans reported large mood swings after wins or losses, yet satisfaction with democracy remained largely unchanged.
- In the Super Bowl and World Cup surveys, feelings changed but democratic views did not.
- In a controlled test, participants watched either the "Hakuna Matata" scene or the scene of Mufasa’s death to shift mood.
- Those clips altered mood but did not affect attitudes toward democracy.
Singh says, “That was the first big signal,” meaning temporary emotions are unlikely to drive the winner–loser gap. The researchers conclude that democratic legitimacy depends more on policy outcomes and whether governments meet public expectations. They warn that efforts to inflame emotions or vilify opponents will not build durable support and may increase political disaffection. Singh adds a practical note: “Democracy is cyclical. You win some; you lose some.” The study is published in Political Psychology; source: University of Georgia.
Difficult words
- investigate — try to find facts or learn about somethinginvestigated
- satisfaction — feeling that something meets your hopes or needs
- democracy — system of government in which people choose leaders
- expectation — belief about what will happen in the futureexpectations
- isolate — separate one thing to see its individual effect
- legitimacy — general belief that a government is rightful and accepted
- disaffection — feeling of dissatisfaction and loss of public support
- cyclical — happening repeatedly in regular cycles over time
Tip: hover, focus or tap highlighted words in the article to see quick definitions while you read or listen.
Discussion questions
- Do you agree that policy outcomes matter more than short-term emotions for support of democracy? Why or why not?
- Can you think of an example where a sporting event or cultural moment changed public mood but not political opinions? Describe it.
- What actions could governments take to meet public expectations and strengthen democratic legitimacy?
Related articles
AI and fake media in Bangladesh’s election
Before the February 12 election that followed a July 2024 student uprising, AI-generated images, videos and edited photocards spread false stories. Fact-checkers and a study found many cases of manipulation that targeted leaders and parties.
