Political scientists have long noted that election winners often report higher satisfaction with democracy than losers. To test whether this is just a short emotional effect, Shane P. Singh and colleagues used a different approach: they looked at situations that change feelings but have no political consequences.
The team surveyed people in the Cincinnati and Los Angeles regions before and after the 2022 Super Bowl. Fans of the winning team felt happier, but their satisfaction with democracy did not change in any meaningful way. They repeated the study around the 2022 World Cup final between Argentina and France and found the same result.
In a controlled experiment, participants watched either the "Hakuna Matata" scene from The Lion King or the scene showing Mufasa’s death. The clips altered mood but had no effect on views of democracy. Singh says these findings show emotions alone do not explain the winner–loser gap; democratic legitimacy depends more on policy results and whether governments meet expectations. The research appears in Political Psychology and the source is the University of Georgia.
Difficult words
- satisfaction — feeling that needs or expectations are met
- democracy — system where people elect their government
- survey — ask many people the same questionssurveyed
- experiment — test done to learn what happens
- emotion — strong feeling like happiness or angeremotions
- legitimacy — acceptance that a government is lawful
- policy — plan or set of actions by government
Tip: hover, focus or tap highlighted words in the article to see quick definitions while you read or listen.
Discussion questions
- Have you ever felt a non-political event (like a sports win) change your mood? How did it affect your opinions about society or politics?
- Do you agree that government performance matters more than short emotions for trust in democracy? Why or why not?
- What kinds of non-political events in your country might change many people’s mood? Give one or two examples and explain.
Related articles
AI to stop tobacco targeting young people
At a World Conference in Dublin (23–25 June), experts said artificial intelligence can help stop tobacco companies targeting young people online. They warned social media and new nicotine products draw youth into addiction, and poorer countries carry the heaviest burden.
Eclipse project increased people’s connection to science
A public participatory science project linked to the 2024 total solar eclipse showed that witnessing awe-inspiring events can raise people’s sense of science identity and belonging. Volunteers recorded animal behaviour and completed surveys.
