March Madness and bracket contests highlight a common tension between informed prediction and random events. Millions of people fill brackets each year, using analysis and judgment to pick winners and forecast upsets, yet the tournament outcome often hinges on luck.
The illusion of control in psychology describes the common tendency to overestimate how much personal choices affect events that are actually driven by chance. In the context of March Madness this illusion is visible when expert picks feel sensible, but a single bad game, a lucky shot, or an untimely injury can rapidly change the tournament and make many brackets fail.
Albert Cohen of Michigan State University explains the role of skill and luck in bracket success. His positions include:
- Director, graduate certificate in sports analytics
- Director, Actuarial Science Program
- Senior academic specialist, math and statistics and probability departments
Cohen points out that statistics and actuarial science connect closely to sports, and that bracket performance can reflect preparation as well as chance. Futurity published the original post presenting his views.
Difficult words
- tension — conflict or strain between opposing ideas or forces
- informed — based on knowledge, evidence, or careful thought
- random — happening without order or predictability
- illusion of control — belief that choices influence outcomes more than chance
- overestimate — think something is greater or more likely than true
- actuarial — relating to statistical risk and financial calculations
- upset — an unexpected result in a competition or eventupsets
Tip: hover, focus or tap highlighted words in the article to see quick definitions while you read or listen.
Discussion questions
- Have you ever filled a tournament bracket? How much did you rely on analysis versus luck?
- How can awareness of the illusion of control change the way people make predictions about events?
- What role can statistics or actuarial methods play in improving sports predictions like brackets?
Related articles
Family background and graduates' wage expectations
A study of college-educated job seekers in China followed two groups for three months and recorded weekly wage expectations. Graduates from lower-class families set lower initial wages and adjusted them more; researchers recommend wage-setting coaching at universities.
