New research appearing in The Milbank Quarterly, produced by teams including scholars at the University of Michigan, Harvard and Duke, argues that many ultraprocessed products share important qualities with tobacco. Drawing on addiction science, nutrition research and the history of tobacco regulation, the analysis finds that packaged snacks, sugary beverages, ready-to-eat meals and many fast foods can be industrially engineered to amplify reward in the brain, encourage habitual use and shape public perception in ways that protect company profits.
Study first author Ashley Gearhardt, a University of Michigan professor of clinical psychology, notes that certain snacks can feel unusually hard to put down. She is careful to say the takeaway is not that eating is the same as smoking. Rather, the study highlights how design choices in production and marketing can make moderation more difficult for many people.
The authors call for a change in public health thinking. For decades messages emphasized personal responsibility, but the paper urges a focus on larger systems — what appears on shelves, what is affordable and what is heavily marketed — and suggests food policy could follow tobacco policy by moving from blaming individuals to holding companies accountable. The research was reported by the University of Michigan and appeared on Futurity.
Difficult words
- ultraprocessed — heavily industrially manufactured and highly processed food
- amplify — make a feeling or effect stronger
- habitual — done regularly and without much thought
- moderation — controlled or limited amount of something
- accountable — required to explain actions and accept responsibility
- engineer — design or build something for a specific purposeengineered
- perception — the way people understand or interpret something
Tip: hover, focus or tap highlighted words in the article to see quick definitions while you read or listen.
Discussion questions
- Do you think food policy should follow tobacco policy by holding companies accountable? Why or why not?
- How might industrial design and marketing of ultraprocessed foods affect people's everyday choices? Give examples.
- What public health measures could make moderation of packaged snacks and sugary drinks easier for consumers?
Related articles
Study warns of heavier rain and hotter nights in Tanzania
New research warns parts of Tanzania will see more extreme rainfall and rising temperatures. Experts say farmers, health and cities will be affected and call for stronger national policies, preparedness and community climate finance.
Targeting Glut1 in Neutrophils Reduces Kidney Damage
Researchers using a mouse model of antibody-mediated glomerulonephritis found that neutrophils increase Glut1, a glucose transporter. Disabling Glut1 in neutrophils or using a Glut1 inhibitor reduced inflammation and improved kidney pathology in the model.
Action still needed to end hunger and change food systems
Experts say stronger action is needed after the 2021 UN Food Systems Summit. They note progress in research and national plans, but rising conflicts, climate extremes and funding limits put progress at risk. A stocktake will take place in Ethiopia this month.
Low-cost cooling could help Bangladesh garment workers
A University of Sydney study, published in The Lancet Planetary Health on Monday (20 October), tested simple low-cost cooling in a chamber that mimicked extreme factory heat. Fans and water partly restored productivity; a reflective roof cut indoor temperature by 2.5°C.