Researchers at the University of Notre Dame report that conventional measures overstate the effectiveness of traditional television advertising. The result is important because advertisers continue to allocate far more to linear TV — roughly $139 billion this year — than to streaming and connected TV, which are expected to receive $33 billion.
The team, led by Shijie Lu with Tsung-Yiou Hsieh and Rex Yuxing Du, linked second-by-second viewing data from LG smart TVs to purchases on a food delivery app. They analyzed activity for millions of opt-in households over a four-month period and focused on broadcast networks such as NBC and ABC; the study did not track streaming apps like Hulu or Amazon. By exploiting natural timing differences — for example, whether a household watched the part of a live game when a given ad aired — the researchers created a natural experiment that separates true ad effects from confounding factors.
The authors find that methods based on ratings and aggregate market data overestimate ad effectiveness by 55% in this context. The study also offers practical insights:
- Promotions for first-time buyers increase retention.
- Viewer responsiveness peaks within two days of a purchase, with highest engagement among customers who ordered two to four times before.
- Younger, tech-savvy sports fans respond better than older news viewers.
The researchers conclude that isolating ad exposure timing allows more precise measurement of return on investment and can help target TV ads based on actual purchase behavior rather than only demographic data. Source: University of Notre Dame
Difficult words
- overstate — present something as larger or more effective than true
- allocate — set aside money or resources for a purpose
- opt-in — agree to join or allow participation or data use
- confound — make cause and effect hard to separate or see clearlyconfounding
- retention — continued use or repeat purchase by customers
- responsiveness — speed and strength of people's reactions to ads
Tip: hover, focus or tap highlighted words in the article to see quick definitions while you read or listen.
Discussion questions
- How could advertisers use second-by-second TV viewing data to improve ad targeting and spending decisions?
- What privacy or ethical concerns arise from linking smart TV viewing data to purchases, even for opt-in households?
- Given the study's finding that conventional measures overstate TV ad effectiveness, would you change ad budgets between linear TV and streaming? Why or why not?
Related articles
Removing Cookies Cuts Online Ad Revenue
A Boston University study finds that removing third-party cookies substantially reduced publisher ad revenue, with larger losses in the EU. Google’s Privacy Sandbox recovered only a small share, and publishers are changing how they earn money online.
UNESCO report finds gaps in education data
A UNESCO report published on 27 April finds important gaps in education data from poorer countries. It reviewed primary and secondary data in 120 countries but under‑represented low‑income nations and found no science assessment data in low‑income countries.
AI expands sexual and reproductive health access in Latin America
Research groups in Peru and Argentina use AI tools to give sexual and reproductive health information to young and marginalised people. Experts praise potential but warn of bias and call for better data, rules and oversight.