Rose-shaped toy in Trinidad Carnival causes debate ^{CEFR B2}

The inclusion of a rose-shaped sex toy in goody bags by the band Tribe has prompted a broad debate ahead of Trinidad and Tobago’s national Carnival. Unboxing videos on social media amplified the story, and reactions ranged from moral condemnation to defence of Carnival culture and commercial motives.

Roman Catholic Archbishop Jason Gordon criticised the gift from the pulpit, saying it had “gone too far” and warning that government regulation might become necessary if bands did not limit content. Tribe leader Dean Ackin told the Trinidad Express that Carnival is about “freedom, expression, fun and a little mischief” and that the band aims to keep the experience “fresh, playful and memorable.”

Commentary was divided. A widely shared post referenced a Guardian op‑ed framing the “Rose” toy as cultural hedonism, while Wired868 columnist Jessica Joseph argued Carnival has roots in a planned release of desire and protest. Others, including cultural activist Tillah Willah, noted that outrage can become publicity and that commercial incentives shape band behaviour. Gender and safety perspectives, voiced by writers and academics like Gabrielle Hosein, pointed to communal erotic expression and warned against a moral panic. Critics also asked why the Archbishop has not spoken as forcefully about other recent public issues.

Parents and some masqueraders said the gift was unacceptable and questioned its message for young people. Calls for accountability and the possibility of formal regulation remain part of the public discussion.