Rose-shaped toy in Trinidad Carnival causes debateCEFR B1
15 Feb 2026
Adapted from Janine Mendes-Franco, Global Voices • CC BY 3.0
Photo by Sonika Agarwal, Unsplash
A well-known Carnival band, Tribe, put an adult toy shaped like a rose into goody bags for its women masqueraders. Unboxing videos on social media made the item a public controversy and drew attention from bloggers and news sites.
Roman Catholic Archbishop Jason Gordon criticised the gift from the pulpit, saying the move had “gone too far” and suggesting possible government regulation if bands did not restrain themselves. Tribe leader Dean Ackin defended the choice, saying Carnival is about “freedom, expression, fun and a little mischief” and that the band wants the experience to be “fresh, playful and memorable.”
Responses split along cultural, moral and commercial lines. Commentators linked the incident to capitalism, class and marketing that uses female sensuality. Gender and safety voices added that some women prefer solo sexual autonomy and that solo activity reduces pregnancy and STI risk. Parents and others called for accountability, and debate about possible regulation continues.
Difficult words
- masquerader — person who participates in a masked festivalmasqueraders
- unboxing — video of opening a packaged item
- controversy — public disagreement or argument about something
- pulpit — platform in a church for public speaking
- regulation — official rule made by a government or organisation
- sensuality — quality of sexual or physical attractiveness and pleasure
- autonomy — ability to make decisions for oneself
- accountability — responsibility to explain or justify actions
Tip: hover, focus or tap highlighted words in the article to see quick definitions while you read or listen.
Discussion questions
- Do you think Carnival bands should check items before putting them in goody bags? Why or why not?
- How can bands balance freedom and expression with respect for all participants?
- What kinds of regulation, if any, would be appropriate after this controversy and why?
Related articles
Debate in India after evolution removed from school books
Science educators in India ask the government to restore Darwinian evolution material that NCERT removed from school science textbooks to reduce study load after the COVID-19 pandemic. Hundreds of scientists have criticised the permanent removal.
Zenica School of Comics: Art and Education for Children
The Zenica School of Comics began during the 1992–95 war and has taught around 200 young artists. The school still runs, faces changes from tablets and AI, and the regional comics scene survives through festivals and cooperation.
Culturally Wise Programs Help Women in Niger
A University of Michigan study published in PNAS finds that programs matching local values help women in rural Niger more than Western-style interventions. The research says social and psychological factors affect people’s ability to improve their lives.
Citizen archivists record South Asian oral traditions
Citizen archivists in South Asia record folk songs, oral histories, riddles and traditional medicinal knowledge. They upload videos and transcriptions to Wikimedia Commons, Wikisource and Wikipedia to preserve fading cultural knowledge.