Research published in Nature Neuroscience asked whether brain predictions work like the next-word predictions used in phones and large language models (LLMs). Coauthor David Poeppel explains that while LLMs are trained to predict the next word, the human brain makes predictions by grammatically grouping words into phrases.
The study tested Mandarin Chinese speakers and recorded brain activity with magnetoencephalography (MEG). It also used behavioral Cloze tests, where people fill missing words, and the team examined additional brain data from patients exposed to English to check cross-language consistency.
To compare brain responses and model behavior, the researchers used LLMs to compute entropy (many possible continuations) and surprisal (how unexpected a word is). If the brain worked like an LLM, correlations between brain signals and model predictions would be uniformly high. Instead, brain responses varied with a word’s position inside grammatical structure, showing sensitivity to constituents. The authors conclude human prediction is balanced and modulated by grammatically organized chunks, not just next-word probability.
Difficult words
- entropy — measure of unpredictability among many options
- surprisal — how unexpected an event or item is
- magnetoencephalography — a brain activity recording method using magnetic fieldsmagnetoencephalography (MEG)
- cloze test — task where people fill missing wordsCloze tests
- constituent — a group of words that form a unitconstituents
- modulate — to change strength or level of somethingmodulated
Tip: hover, focus or tap highlighted words in the article to see quick definitions while you read or listen.
Discussion questions
- Do you think your brain predicts words more like an LLM or by grouping words into grammatical chunks? Why?
- Why is it useful for researchers to test speakers of different languages, such as Mandarin and English, in this study?
- How might the finding that prediction is modulated by grammatical chunks affect text prediction tools on phones?
Related articles
Digital harassment of women journalists in Indonesia
Online attacks against female journalists and activists in Indonesia have become more visible in the last five years. Victims report doxing, edited photos, DDoS and other abuse, while legal protection and platform responses remain limited.
New cocoa fermenting box boosts farmers' incomes
In Kasawo, a locally made single cocoa fermenting box improves bean fermentation and helps farmers sell directly to exporters. Researchers report faster, better fermentation, higher prices and plans to scale up production across cocoa districts.
Lower mGlu5 receptor found across autistic adult brains
A study in The American Journal of Psychiatry found lower availability of a glutamate receptor called mGlu5 across the brains of autistic adults. Researchers used PET, MRI and EEG and say the result could affect future diagnosis and treatment.