A new study examined how secondhand clothing affects overall fashion consumption. Using a nationally representative survey of 1,009 individuals in every US state, researchers analysed buying and discarding patterns in both resale and primary markets. They found a positive correlation: people who spend in the secondhand market also tend to spend more on new clothes, especially younger shoppers and frequent buyers.
More than 69% of respondents had purchased secondhand clothing at least once, and a cluster of 59% showed high consumption in both markets. Members of that group frequently returned items, kept garments for short periods, and had increased secondhand purchases since 2020. Younger adults were more engaged: 79% of 18-to-24-year-olds had bought secondhand, compared with 57% of those 65 and older, and students reported the highest use at 84%.
The authors draw on two behavioural theories to explain the results: the rebound effect, where efficiency gains raise demand, and moral licensing, where a virtuous act justifies later indulgence. "Our study provides strong evidence that secondhand clothing markets contribute to a self-reinforcing cycle of overconsumption," says Meital Peleg Mizrachi. The researchers recommend that resale platforms disclose metrics such as unsold inventory disposal rates and shipping-related emissions, noting there are no current policies in the United States or Europe regulating resale of secondhand clothes.
Difficult words
- secondhand — Previously owned items, not brand newsecondhand clothing, secondhand market, secondhand purchases
- resale — Selling goods that were previously ownedresale platforms
- consumption — Use, buying, or wearing of goodsoverconsumption
- correlation — A relationship where two things change togetherpositive correlation
- rebound effect — When efficiency gains cause more demand
- moral licensing — Feeling allowed to indulge after a good action
Tip: hover, focus or tap highlighted words in the article to see quick definitions while you read or listen.
Discussion questions
- Why might people who buy more secondhand clothing also buy more new clothes? Give two possible reasons from the article.
- How could resale platforms change their practices to reduce the cycle of overconsumption described in the study?
- Do you think governments should regulate resale of secondhand clothes? Why or why not, based on the article's points?
Related articles
Indigenous leader Dzoodzo Baniwa wins climate award
Dzoodzo Baniwa, from the Alto Río Negro territory in Amazonas, won a Bunge Foundation award for work on the climate emergency and practical agricultural science solutions. The prize highlights links between indigenous knowledge and scientific practice.
Pressure on Kibira National Park from tea farms and development
Tea plantations and other development near Kibira National Park in northwest Burundi have reduced forest cover and made wildlife, including chimpanzees, rarer. Experts and local people call for community action to protect the park.
Study: Whale shark tourism rules broken at El Azul
A study using drone footage found many tourism rule violations at El Azul, a large whale shark site off the Yucatán coast. Researchers recorded boats and swimmers too close to feeding sharks and recommend better monitoring and self-regulation.
Nepal’s cement industry: growth, jobs and pollution
After the 2015 Gorkha earthquake, Nepal expanded cement production with large investments, especially from Chinese firms. By 2019 it became self-sufficient and started exports to India in July 2022, while social and environmental problems grew.