The origin of the Moon matters because it shaped Earth’s early environment. A new multi-institution study finds that the object that struck early Earth—called Theia—probably formed closer to the Sun than Earth did. The work, published in Science, was led by researchers at the University of Chicago, the Max Planck Institute for Solar System Research and the University of Hong Kong.
The team used isotopes—small variations of elements that serve as fingerprints for where material formed in the early solar system. They made precision measurements of iron and combined them with earlier isotope data for chromium, calcium, titanium, molybdenum and zirconium from terrestrial rocks, six lunar samples returned by the Apollo missions, and meteorites from different solar system regions. Their laboratory develops techniques to measure these tiny differences with great precision.
Models of metal movement during planet formation showed that much of early Earth’s iron and molybdenum likely sank to the core before the impact. That implies a significant fraction of iron now in Earth’s crust and mantle may have come from Theia. Simulations testing different Theia compositions indicate the best isotopic match comes from meteorites that formed in regions nearer the Sun. As a result, the authors conclude Earth and Theia were likely neighbors, and the Moon’s stabilizing effect on Earth’s tilt was a fortunate outcome for complex life. Funding came from NASA, the National Science Foundation, the US Department of Energy, Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft and the European Research Council.
Difficult words
- origin — the beginning or cause of something
- isotope — variants of an element with different neutron numbersisotopes
- fingerprint — a distinctive trait that shows originfingerprints
- precision — accuracy in measurement or detail
- composition — what something is made ofcompositions
- simulation — computer models that imitate real processesSimulations
- mantle — the layer between a planet's surface and core
- core — the central part of a planet
- crust — the outer solid layer of a planet
- stabilize — to make something more steady or stablestabilizing
Tip: hover, focus or tap highlighted words in the article to see quick definitions while you read or listen.
Discussion questions
- How might the Moon's stabilizing effect on Earth's tilt have influenced the development of complex life? Explain your reasons.
- Why are isotope measurements useful for studying where early solar system material formed? Give an example from the article.
- What additional evidence or approaches would you suggest to confirm whether Theia formed nearer the Sun?
Related articles
How relationships shape memories of childhood adversity
A study of nearly 1,000 emerging adults found that memories of adverse childhood experiences change with the quality of current relationships, especially with parents. The researchers suggest asking about these experiences more than once.
Study: Many small galaxies may lack central black holes
A University of Michigan-led study using Chandra X-ray data finds many dwarf galaxies do not show signs of central supermassive black holes. The result suggests the biggest black holes may have formed large early and could be tested by future missions.
Oxytocin rises in soccer contests among the Tsimane
Researchers from the University of Zurich measured oxytocin during soccer tournaments with the Indigenous Tsimane in the Bolivian Amazon. Levels rose most against familiar rivals and also rose versus outsiders; changes appeared in men but not women.
Uganda report urges reform of science and innovation
A national report launched on 21 June says Uganda must reform its science, technology and innovation systems to move faster toward middle-income status. It highlights gender gaps, weak funding and calls for stronger links between research, government and business.